UX Detail Review

Deliver a detail-level UX review that focuses on moments where users hesitate, mistrust, or lose flow.

Workflow

1. Capture review context.

• Identify artifact type (screenshot, prototype, live page, app screen).
• Identify target user action (for example: sign up, buy, submit, compare, search).
• Identify constraints (mobile/desktop, locale, accessibility needs, release scope).

2. Run a 6-lens detail audit.

• Action feedback: Verify each user action has immediate, visible confirmation.
• Loading behavior: Check whether waiting states match task context and user intent.
• Interaction honesty: Detect deceptive or hostile interaction patterns.
• Native conventions: Check alignment with platform expectations and learned patterns.
• Motion quality: Review transitions and micro-animations for clarity, not decoration.
• Microcopy tone: Review labels, hints, errors, and empty states for clarity and respect.

3. Record evidence before suggesting fixes.

• Tie each finding to a concrete UI element, state, or path step.
• Describe the current behavior and user impact in one sentence each.
• Avoid abstract opinions that cannot be observed.

4. Prioritize improvements.

• P0: Blocks completion, causes likely abandonment, or creates major trust risk.
• P1: Significant friction on key journeys.
• P2: Noticeable polish gap with moderate user impact.
• P3: Nice-to-have refinement.

5. Propose fix + validation per finding.

• Give one concrete change recommendation.
• Define a validation method (usability check, event metric, A/B, or heuristic re-test).
• Prefer fixes that can be implemented in the current release cycle.

Required Output Shape

Use the structure in assets/review-template.md.

Non-negotiables:

• Include severity (P0 to P3) for every finding.
• Include expected user impact and suggested implementation effort.
• If no issues are found, state that explicitly and list residual risk areas.

Reference Files

• Core principles and checklist: references/god-is-in-the-details.md
• Response scaffold: assets/review-template.md

Read only the files above unless the user requests deeper expansion.